Schools reopening without masking is ‘formula for disaster,’ Louisiana children’s hospital doctor says
By Madeline Holcombe and Lauren Mascarenhas, CNN
Opening schools full of unvaccinated children without requiring them to wear masks or take other precautions is a recipe for disaster, the physician-in-chief of Children’s Hospital New Orleans says.
“I think bringing together large numbers of children, congregating them in classrooms with masks being optional — or worse yet even, forbidden — is just a formula for disaster,” Dr. Mark Kline told CNN’s Don Lemon.
Kline cited Louisiana’s mask mandate for schools and said it would be wise for governors across the region to follow suit.
“This virus that we’re dealing with now is a game changer, and it’s just so easily transmitted from person-to-person that this could truly catalyze an explosion of cases across the region,” he added.
It’s not just students who could soon see mandates. Dr. Anthony Fauci, director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, said on MSNBC on Tuesday that he thinks vaccines for teachers should be mandated.
“We are in a critical situation now,” he said. “We’ve had 615,000-plus deaths and we are in a major surge now as we’re going into the fall, into the school season. This is very serious business. You would wish that people would see why it’s so important to get vaccinated.”
As Americans gear up for a new school year against a backdrop of rising Covid-19 cases, experts say there is no time to waste in getting already rising vaccination rates even higher.
The US is currently averaging 486,332 people initiating vaccinations a day, which is a 10% increase over last week’s pace and the highest daily average since June 18, according to data published Monday by the CDC.
Though the improvements are promising, more Americans still need to get vaccinated as quickly as possible, especially considering that it takes six weeks from the first injection for people to be fully protected, Dr. Thomas Frieden said, former director of the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Just over half of the total population is fully vaccinated, while about 31% of the vaccine-eligible population has not been vaccinated.
The large swath of the population still unvaccinated is even more of a concern as cases rise. With an average of more than 116,600 new Covid-19 cases per day, it’s the highest in about six months, according to data from Johns Hopkins University.
And rates of hospitalizations and deaths have almost doubled in the past two weeks. More than 68,000 people are hospitalized with Covid-19, according to data from the Department of Health and Human Services.
More than 99.99% of people who are fully vaccinated against Covid-19 have not had a breakthrough case resulting in hospitalization or death, according to a CNN analysis of data from the CDC.
But as effective as vaccines are, Frieden said that with too low of rates, vaccination may need to be paired with mask mandates.
“What we know really well is that vaccines work and masks work,” he said. “Doubling the protection is particularly important because we have this doubly infectious variant of Delta.
School mask mandate debate escalates
Concerns over the rise in cases are growing for many as parents begin to send their children to school for the new year.
A CNN analysis from August 5 found that at least seven states — Arkansas, Arizona, Iowa, Oklahoma, South Carolina, Texas, and Utah — prohibit districts from requiring masks in schools.
On August 6, an Arkansas judge temporarily blocked the enforcement of the state’s law banning mask mandates in schools, in response to two lawsuits — one from a school district, and one from parents — who want schools to be able to require masks if they so choose. School districts are allowed to enforce mask mandates while the suit continues.
Florida does not technically ban school districts from requiring masks, but Gov. Ron DeSantis has pulled other levers to reach the same point. The governor’s office said in statement Monday the state board of education “could” move to withhold the salary of the district superintendent or school board members in districts that made masks mandatory in schools.
Superintendent for Alachua Public Schools Carlee Simon, whose school district is defying DeSantis’ attempted ban on mask mandates, said she doesn’t believe he’s taking the surge in cases in northeast Florida seriously.
“The governor should take the conservative step and do everything he can to protect the lives everyone in our community,” Simon told CNN’s Lemon. “I believe the governor has other interests that he’s focusing on,” Simon added.
DeSantis Tuesday defended his ban on school mask mandates saying, for him, “It is about parental choice, not government mandate.”
The governor said “a lot of parents” have come to him and complained that masking is hard on their children in a learning environment.
Schools are scheduled to reopen Tuesday in Florida and Simon says she and other school officials are concerned about the rising positivity rate in the state.
“My goal is to make sure that I provide the high quality education and this is a direction I believe I need to go,” Simon said. “It’s concerning because we need to be able to run schools and we need to make sure that people aren’t testing positive or needing to quarantine.”
One health expert said that vaccine mandates for children 12 to 17 may be necessary as the new school year begins.
Speaking about the rise in pediatric ICU admissions in certain parts of the country, Dr. Peter Hotez, a vaccinologist and dean of the National School of Tropical Medicine at Baylor College of Medicine, told CNN’s Wolf Blitzer that “schools are going to be an accelerant” for child infections without universal masking.
“It’s not even going to be enough to have mask mandates in the schools,” he said. “We need all of the adolescents vaccinated, and really we need to move towards vaccine mandates for the 12 to 17-year-olds in the schools.”
Some states only have a quarter of the adolescent population vaccinated, Hotez said, so both mask and an increase in vaccination rates among students will be important to containing in-school spread.
“If we’re going to give our fighting chance to have a successful school year, we’re going to need everyone who is vaccine eligible to get vaccinated and everybody masked,” Hotez said.
The-CNN-Wire
™ & © 2021 Cable News Network, Inc., a WarnerMedia Company. All rights reserved.
CNN’s Gregory Lemos, Keith Allen, Claudia Dominguez, Camille Furst, Jennifer Henderson, Jacqueline Howard, Virginia Langmaid, Lauren Mascarenhas, Evan McMorris-Santoro, Deidre McPhillips, Elizabeth Stuart, Naomi Thomas and Amara Walker contributed to this report.
