Diamond Princess cruise passengers disembark after 14-day quarantine ends in Japan, raising concerns among health experts
Passengers who have tested negative for the novel coronavirus began disembarking from the stricken Diamond Princess cruise ship Wednesday, despite mounting evidence from infectious disease experts they could unknowingly be carrying the virus back into their communities.
These are the first passengers to leave the vessel following a 14-day quarantine period, not including those undergoing treatment on shore for the virus, and the more than 300 Americans evacuated over the weekend and now in quarantine at two US bases.
A total of 624 confirmed cases of the virus have been linked to the ship during its quarantine in Tokyo Bay, with 79 new cases confirmed on Wednesday.
Passengers over 70 years old who have tested negative were the first to exit the ship on board taxis and buses, with some expected to transition to shoreside facilities and others to board chartered flights, according to the ship’s captain. The disembarkation will take several days. Once passengers have left the ship, they will be permitted to travel freely.
Jan Swartz, President and CEO of the vessel’s operator Princess Cruises, told CNN that this is an “unprecedented situation.” “Nobody going on vacation thinks that they’re going to be notified in the last days that they’ve got an extension … and they’re not going to be allowed to leave their cabins,” she added.
Swartz greeted passengers as they disembarked. She also highlighted the actions of the ship’s crew. Japan did not allow the roughly 1,000 crew members to be quarantined unless they took ill, instead asking them to serve the rest of the passengers throughout the two-week period.
“I think the guests and our crew who came together to help support each other, from 57 different countries and regions around the world, really lifted each other’s hearts.”
Several countries including Australia, Canada and the UK were organizing chartered planes to repatriate their nationals.
Disembarkation sparks concerns
Japan’s efforts to institute quarantine measures aboard the Diamond Princess may have slowed transmission on land, but the disembarkation has sparked wider concerns, with some pointing to a potential breach of public safety.
On Monday, it was revealed that a total of 14 evacuated American passengers developed symptoms only after leaving the ship.
The US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) commended Japan’s quarantine measures but said they may not be sufficient to prevent transmission among individuals in the ship.
“The CDC believes the rate of new infections on board, especially among those without symptoms, represents an ongoing risk,” it said in a statement released Tuesday.
“To protect the health of the American public, all passengers and crew of the ship have been placed under travel restrictions, preventing them from returning to the US for at least 14 days after they have left the Diamond Princess.”
Other experts have also raised the alarm. Kentaro Iwata, an infectious disease specialist at Kobe University who visited the ship, told CNN that he didn’t think it was a proper quarantine.
Iwata has worked on various infectious outbreaks such as Ebola and Sars over the last 20 years, but says he has never been as worried about getting infected himself.
“I was so scared because there was no way to tell where the virus is and everybody was not careful about it,” Iwata told CNN.
“There was no single infection control person inside the ship — the bureaucrats were in charge of everything.”
Iwata called for an extended quarantine period for those passengers leaving the Diamond Princess.
“I think those people who leave the cruise ship today or tomorrow should be monitored for another 14 days because there is high danger of secondary transmission,” Iwata told CNN.
Japan issues health guidelines
Japan has stepped up efforts to contain the spread of the novel coronavirus after an uptick in cases nationwide sparked concern among the public and cast a shadow over the economy and Tokyo’s preparations to host the Summer Olympics.
The country’s health ministry issued guidelines on Monday for people experiencing symptoms similar to the coronavirus in an effort to prevent worried citizens from inundating hospitals by providing them with specific hotlines to call.
People who are feeling lethargic, experiencing shortness of breath, or who have had a temperature of 37.5 Celsius or higher for four days should call nationwide healthcare centers that are in charge of responding to the outbreak, the health ministry advises.
A total of 692 cases of the novel coronavirus have been confirmed in the country — the largest outbreak outside China — including the 624 cases on the Diamond Princess.
On Friday morning, cases unrelated to the ship stood at 31, but by Wednesday that number had risen to 68 following a spike in cases across the country in the past few days. An elderly woman in Kanagawa prefecture is the only person in Japan to have died of the virus.
The guidance comes as Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe held a meeting with medical experts over the weekend and Japan’s health minister warned on Sunday that the nation is “entering a new phase” in the coronavirus outbreak.
“We want to ask the public to avoid non-urgent, non-essential gatherings. We want the elderly and those with pre-existing conditions to avoid crowded places,” health minister Katsunobu Kato said Sunday, after a discussion by a panel of experts. They said Japan was still in the early stages of infection.
Kato said that as it would be difficult to track the source of the infections, Japan could see a rise in cases. He stressed that it was important for medical facilities to prepare themselves in advance to tackle a potential spread of the infection in Japan.
Outbreak response
The coronavirus has spread from Wuhan, the epicenter of the outbreak in central China, to more than 25 countries and regions, killing 2,010 people and infecting more than 75,000 people globally.
Face masks have become scarce in Japan since early February. Amid the shortage, an old tweet from the Tokyo police’s department’s disaster countermeasures division from August 2019 that provides instruction on how to make a DIY mask gained renewed chatter online as people turn to increasingly creative measures to protect themselves.
Japan has already started to take a number of precautions to overcome and prevent the spread of the virus.
Two Japanese airlines — All Nippon Airways and Japan Airlines — announced a reduction or suspension of flights to mainland China due to the coronavirus outbreak on February 4.
On Monday, the Japanese Imperial Household announced it would cancel next weekend’s public birthday celebration for Emperor Naruhito over fears that large crowds could encourage the spread of coronavirus.
The Tokyo Marathon will also only be open to elite athletes due to public health concerns about the novel coronavirus, according to an announcement by event organizers on Monday. So far, Tokyo 2020 Olympic organizers have asserted the preparations for the Games, which are due to officially begin on Friday, July 24, will continue.
More Japanese companies are adopting the practice of encouraging their employees to work from home to prevent exposing them to the virus on congested public transport and in offices.
Japanese telecoms giant NTT is the latest to join a slew of firms encouraging their employees to telework in a bid to protect its workers from the virus.
Earlier in February, Japanese e-commerce giant Rakuten told employees who had recently returned from China to work from home for two weeks, according to public broadcaster NHK. The incubation period of the virus is believed to be 14 days.
Economic impact
Amid fears over the coronavirus outbreak, speculation is growing around the affect it will have on Japan’s tourism industry and economy.
This year, Japan’s popular destinations have seen a slump in tourist numbers as China announced a ban on outbound group travel as part of its battle to stop the spread of the coronavirus outbreak in January.
That particularly affected Japan, which had approximately 9.6 million visitors from China in 2019 — accounting for a third of foreign tourist expenditure in the country.
Japan has struggled to recover from three recessions in the past eight years. It has also absorbed a sales tax hike and grappled with the aftermath of Typhoon Hagibis, a powerful storm that hit the country last fall.
There are concerns the virus could push the country into another recession.
The world’s third-largest economy shrank 1.6% in the fourth quarter of 2019, according to a government estimate released Monday. The decline from the third quarter is the biggest contraction since 2014.
